Quick Verdict
In This Article
How Cleansing Balms Actually Work
Cleansing balms work through a simple chemistry principle: oil dissolves oil. Makeup, SPF, and sebum are all oil-soluble -- meaning a water-based cleanser can't break them down effectively. A balm, massaged onto dry skin, dissolves that oil-soluble layer completely. When you add water, the balm emulsifies and rinses away, taking all that dissolved makeup with it.
What separates a good cleansing balm from a bad one is what it leaves behind. Poorly formulated balms leave a film or greasy residue that can clog pores over time. The best ones emulsify fully and leave skin feeling clean, soft, and ready for the next step. Every pick on this list passes that test. If you want to understand the broader category before buying, the face wash guide covers when a water-based cleanser might be enough -- and when a balm is necessary.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Format | Skin Type | Removes SPF | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clinique Take the Day OffTop Pick | Balm | All Types | Yes | ~$35 | View |
| Banila Co Clean It Zero | Sherbet Balm | All Types | Yes | ~$18 | View |
| DHC Deep Cleansing Oil | Oil | All Types | Yes | ~$28 | View |
| Farmacy Green Clean | Balm | Sensitive | Yes | ~$34 | View |
| Tatcha Pure One Step | Oil | All / Dry | Yes | ~$50 | View |
| Glow Recipe Papaya Sorbet | Balm | Normal / Combo | Yes | ~$38 | View |
| e.l.f. Holy Hydration! | Balm | All Types | Yes | ~$12 | View |
The 7 Best Cleansing Balms on Amazon
Clinique Take the Day Off Cleansing Balm
~$35 · ASIN: B000H2CC5C
Clinique's Take the Day Off is one of the few products in beauty that genuinely earns the word "classic." It's been around for years and it keeps being recommended because it just works. Scoop a small amount onto dry fingertips, massage it across a full face of foundation, concealer, mascara, and SPF -- it melts everything. The texture goes from solid to a silky oil almost immediately with body heat.
What separates it from competitors is the rinse. It emulsifies completely and leaves nothing behind -- no greasiness, no film, no residue in your pores. All skin types tolerate it without complaint. If you've never tried a cleansing balm before, this is the one to start with because it will convert you immediately.
- Removes waterproof mascara and long-wear foundation with no effort
- Rinses completely clean -- no greasy residue
- Fragrance-free and suitable for all skin types including sensitive
- Consistent formula across years -- no reformulation issues
- Available in a travel size for testing before committing
- At $35, it's mid-range -- not expensive, but not as cheap as the e.l.f. option
- The jar packaging requires dipping fingers in, which is slightly less hygienic than tube formats
Banila Co Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm
~$18 · ASIN: B00BD32GRE
This is the one that introduced most Western skincare fans to cleansing balms. Banila Co's Clean It Zero has a signature sherbet texture -- solid in the jar, melting immediately on contact with skin -- that made it a cult hit and it hasn't lost a step. It's lighter than most balms, applies quickly, and spreads easily across the full face without dragging.
The travel-friendly compact jar makes it an easy carry-on choice. For the price, the performance is hard to beat -- it removes heavy makeup completely and rinses clean without the residue problems that plague some budget options. The original formula is fragrance-free; if you want added skin benefits, Banila Co also makes a moisturizing and brightening variant, though the original is the one worth starting with.
- Sherbet texture melts into skin instantly -- very fast to apply
- Affordable price point for the quality delivered
- Compact jar format is excellent for travel
- Removes full-coverage foundation and waterproof formulas reliably
- Rinses without leaving film
- Jar format means fingers-in-product contact every use
- The original is straightforward -- no bonus skin benefits beyond cleansing
DHC Deep Cleansing Oil
~$28 · ASIN: B004CM29QS
If you prefer a liquid over a solid format, DHC Deep Cleansing Oil is the industry gold standard. Pure olive oil base with vitamin E and rosemary leaf extract -- straightforward, effective, and genuinely well-tolerated by almost every skin type. It's been the benchmark cleansing oil for over two decades and it remains that for a reason. A small amount covers the entire face and emulsifies beautifully with water, turning milky and rinsing away with zero residue.
The olive oil base makes it particularly good for dry skin -- the cleansing step leaves skin comfortable rather than stripped. Pump bottle format is more hygienic than jar-style balms and easier to control the amount you use. If you've been hesitant about oil cleansers because of breakout concerns, DHC is the one with the longest track record of not causing congestion.
- Industry gold standard -- two decades of consistent performance
- Olive oil base leaves dry skin soft and comfortable
- Pump bottle is hygienic and easy to portion
- Emulsifies completely -- no residue
- Well-tolerated by acne-prone skin when rinsed thoroughly
- Liquid format can feel less controlled than a balm
- Olive oil scent is noticeable -- not for those sensitive to natural fragrance
- Slightly more prone to spillage when traveling compared to jar balms
Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Meltaway Cleansing Balm
~$34 · ASIN: B07BQVK98C
Farmacy's Green Clean is the gentlest formulated balm on this list. Sunflower oil and ginger root form the base; there's no synthetic fragrance, no essential oils that could irritate reactive skin, and no harsh emulsifiers. It's the right pick for anyone dealing with rosacea, eczema around the face, or a compromised barrier who still needs a proper first cleanse to remove makeup and SPF.
It doesn't skimp on performance in the name of being gentle. Full-coverage foundation, mascara, and chemical SPF all come off in one pass. The texture is a smooth balm that melts into a silky oil -- the emulsification step leaves skin feeling nourished rather than just clean. Pair it with a very mild foam cleanser as a second step and you have one of the most skin-barrier-friendly double cleanse combos available.
- No synthetic fragrance -- genuinely safe for reactive, sensitive skin
- Sunflower and ginger root base is calming, not stripping
- Removes makeup and waterproof SPF effectively despite gentle formula
- Leaves skin nourished, not tight
- Slightly higher price for the quantity
- The extra-gentle formula means it takes a thorough massage to remove very heavy makeup
- Jar packaging like most balms
Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil
~$50 · ASIN: B012LXNKAG
Tatcha's cleansing oil is the most indulgent first-cleanse step available at this price range. Japanese camellia oil is the lead ingredient -- one of the most skin-compatible oils in formulation, known for its light, fast-absorbing texture that closely mirrors the fatty acid profile of healthy skin sebum. It doesn't feel like cleaning your face; it feels like a facial treatment. Makeup comes off without effort and the oil sinks in without leaving any film.
At $50, you're paying for the ingredient quality, the sourcing, and the experience as much as the cleansing function. The result is real: skin after Tatcha's cleansing oil genuinely looks softer and more luminous than after most balms. If your first-cleanse step has felt like a chore, this turns it into something you look forward to at the end of the day.
- Japanese camellia oil base is exceptional for skin texture over time
- Sinks in completely -- no greasy, filmy feeling at all
- Softens and nourishes while cleansing
- Fragrance-light, appropriate for most skin types including dry and combination
- $50 is a steep price point for a cleanser that rinses off
- Liquid oil format is slightly less portable than balms for travel
- Performance gain over Clinique or DHC is real but marginal
Glow Recipe Papaya Sorbet Enzyme Cleansing Balm
~$38 · ASIN: B078GGQVJY
Most cleansing balms are one-job products: remove makeup. Glow Recipe's Papaya Sorbet does that and adds a layer of very gentle exfoliation on top, courtesy of papaya enzymes that dissolve dead skin cells while you cleanse. The result is skin that looks slightly more refined and brighter than after a standard balm cleanse -- not dramatically, but noticeably over consistent use.
The sorbet texture is genuinely fun to use -- it's a category-specific pleasure that's hard to describe until you've tried it. The enzymes are mild enough to use nightly without irritation for normal and combination skin types. If you're using retinol or acid treatments on other nights, alternate this in rather than stacking exfoliation. As a two-in-one makeup remover and gentle exfoliant, the $38 price point is defensible.
- Dual-action: removes makeup and gently exfoliates in one step
- Papaya enzymes are mild enough for regular use
- Sorbet texture is genuinely enjoyable to apply
- Leaves skin looking noticeably brighter over time
- Not for very sensitive or compromised skin -- enzymes can irritate reactive types
- $38 for an exfoliating first-cleanse is a specific indulgence
- Should not be combined with other exfoliants on the same night
e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
~$12 · ASIN: B09CJKB9YQ
At $12, the e.l.f. Holy Hydration cleansing balm punches considerably above its price point. Hyaluronic acid is worked into the formula, which means the first-cleanse step is also doing light hydration work rather than just stripping. Makeup -- including mascara and long-wear formulas -- comes off reliably. It rinses clean without residue, which is the main thing you need a cleansing balm to do and the thing budget products often fail at.
This is the right starting pick for someone who isn't sure if cleansing balms are worth the habit change, or who needs a solid everyday option without spending $30-50 on a cleanser. There's no meaningful gap in makeup removal efficacy between this and the Clinique. The Clinique wins on formula refinement, rinse feel, and long-term track record -- but if you're deciding whether the category works for you, the e.l.f. will tell you everything you need to know at a fraction of the cost.
- Excellent value -- $12 for full-performing cleansing balm
- Hyaluronic acid adds light hydration to the first-cleanse step
- Removes makeup including waterproof mascara cleanly
- Rinses without residue -- passes the critical test
- Great entry point for first-time cleansing balm users
- Doesn't have the refined texture or rinse feel of Clinique or Tatcha
- Slightly waxy texture compared to the Banila Co sherbet or Farmacy's smooth balm
Keep Building Your Routine
Cleansing Balm FAQ
What is the difference between cleansing balm and cleansing oil?
Cleansing balms are solid at room temperature and melt into an oil when warmed between fingers. Cleansing oils start liquid. Both use oil-based emulsification to dissolve makeup and SPF -- the mechanism is identical. Balms are generally easier to travel with and give more control over how much product you use. Oils are slightly faster to apply and rinse. Choose based on format preference -- the cleansing results are comparable.
Should I double cleanse?
Double cleansing -- oil/balm first, then a water-based cleanser -- is the most thorough way to clean your skin, especially if you wear SPF or full makeup. The first cleanse removes the oil-soluble layer (makeup, SPF, pollutants). The second cleanse removes any remaining residue and cleanses the skin itself. For light makeup days or if you don't wear SPF, a single balm cleanse is sufficient. For heavy makeup or waterproof SPF, double cleansing gives noticeably cleaner skin.
Can cleansing balms cause breakouts?
Oil-based cleansers have a bad reputation for causing breakouts, but this is largely myth for correctly formulated products. Most quality cleansing balms are non-comedogenic and emulsify completely without leaving a pore-clogging residue. Issues arise when people don't rinse thoroughly -- always follow with water and a light foam if prone to congestion. DHC and Clinique's formulas are particularly well-tested for not causing breakouts.
How do I use a cleansing balm correctly?
Apply to dry skin (no water first -- water prevents the emulsification). Massage gently across the face for 30-60 seconds to dissolve makeup and SPF. Add a small amount of water to emulsify -- the product will turn milky. Rinse thoroughly with lukewarm water. Follow with a gentle water-based cleanser if double cleansing. Pat dry and continue routine.
Get the best picks in your inbox
New reviews and curated finds, delivered weekly. No spam, ever.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.